My Take On Chicken Pot Pie Soup

Last week, I read an article on PopSugar about Chrissy Teigen’s chicken pot pie soup recipe belonging to Soup Hall of Fame. As i read the recipe, it validated one of Internet’s solid truths—anyone can post anything online and and call it the best of whatever. It’s just up to you to believe it.

I’ve been making chicken pot pie and its soup version since forever. I’ve done it often enough that i have innovated the crap out of it. Any method that can create the exact same thing at half the time is what innovation dreams are made of. As good as Chrissy’s recipe is, I doubt that such method will take less than 20 minutes. MINE CAN! Not to mention that mine, like most of my favorite dishes, use only one pot…

This is my cast of characters:

rotisserie chicken, potato,carrots,onions, celery,milk, chicken stock,pie crust, butter
rotisserie chicken, potato,carrots,onions, celery,milk, chicken stock,pie crust, butter

Preheat toaster oven. Yep, just your trusty little toaster. Set at 400.

Per pie crust box instruction, add 2 tablespoons of cold water to half the package, form into ball. You don’t need a food processor for this, just your own God-given two hands. I have tried frozen pie crust, it is not as flaky. This pie-crust box is the closest thing to that of my right-from-scratch recipe.

this literally takes about 30 seconds to mix. Note that it is not smooth. Just make sure that the water is mixed in well and you're good to go.
this literally takes about 30 seconds to mix. Note that it is not smooth. Just make sure that the water is mixed in well and you’re good to go.
flatten to about half an inch.
flatten to about half an inch.
set in pan and poke roles on it using a fork.
set in pan and poke roles on it using a fork. bake this for 13-15 minutes. If you have convection toaster oven like mine, 12 minutes is enough

You can be OC about this and form it into squares, but trust me, it doesn’t make a difference. I put a foil on top of the pan then sprayed it with butter. This saves a lot of time when doing clean-up. I cannot tell you enough how much I hate scrubbing grease stains from my pans.

While this bakes, put the butter in the pan then start mincing the chicken breast then cut up one potato into cubes. When butter is hot add the onion-celery mix.

HEB has a mix of onion and celery. It's about a cup each. IT costs about $3 and saves you at least ten minutes of meal prep.
HEB has a mix of cut onion and celery. It’s about a cup each. It costs about $3 and saves you at least ten minutes of meal prep. Sooo worth it.

Cook for about 2 minutes, high heat.

Add about 3 tablespoons of flour, then cook for 2 minutes more.
Add about 3 tablespoons of flour, then cook for 2 minutes more.

Most recipes will use another pan to make a roux (cooked flour), to thicken the soup. Here’s a universal truth: any stock that is added to flour cooked in butter  WILL THICKEN. It doesn’t matter if celery and onions are in the mix, that baby will come out thick and hearty.

So here comes my chicken stock, I use about half of the box.
So here comes my chicken stock, I use about 3 cups.
Followed by about a cup of milk.
Followed by about a cup of milk.

All this time, keep it on high heat.

Add the chicken, potatoes and the cut carrots.
Add the chicken, potatoes and the cut carrots.

As soon as it comes to a boil, turn down to medium heat then cover the pot for 10 minutes.

This actually took less than ten minutes to cook. The potatoes were about 1 square cm, so it cooked really fast.
This actually took less than ten minutes to cook. The potatoes were about 1 square cm, so it cooked really fast.

Just as the soup is wrapping up….take a peek at the pie crust.

The Pie crust looks divine!
The Pie crust looks divine!
Voila! My chicken pot pie soup!!!
Voila! My chicken pot pie soup!!!

This is one hearty comfort food that you can make in a flash. And because I am not married to John Legend, PopSugar will never publish my version and crown it as a Soup Hall of Famer….haha. Bitterness aside, I actually like Chrissy Teigen. I find her funny and pretty. If I didn’t have a gazillion unread cookbooks already, I would buy one of hers too.

Anyway…this is what  we’ll have for dinner. D will enjoy my commentaries about the article  and will probably offer to sing “All of Me” to  make me laugh,  to which I will have to politely decline. We’ve had enough of rain.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *